Skip to content
Brett D. Henderson

The Shepherd’s Path Volume Seven

The Shepherd’s Path to Church Decision Making

How Jesus Chose His Path and How Your Church Can Do the Same

The elders settled it in March. It came back in June, and it is on the agenda again now. Nobody is being difficult. The decision keeps reopening because no one ever agreed what would count as a reason to close it. So every discussion restarts from nothing, the most persistent voice wins by attrition, and the call gets defended afterward rather than made on purpose.

  • StatusDrafted · in editing
  • Written forPastors, elders and leadership teams
  • SeriesBook Seven — the final volume
  • IncludesTeam exercises throughout — it works as a team devotional
  • Grounded inActs 15 as the corporate decision model

Not yet published. The list hears first.

Editing Next: Pre-release

At pre-release, early copies go to the list first.

Trusted by

  • Outreach Magazine
  • The Salvation Army
  • Christian Academy
  • Converge
  • Deeper Bible College
  • Gospel eBooks
  • The Unstuck Group
  • Kailua Assembly of God
  • Impact Church
  • Golden Gate Assembly
  • City on a Hill Church
  • Generation Church
  • Church Tech Today
  • The Summit Church
  • First Assembly of God
  • Williamsburg Christian Academy
  • Oakdale Christian Academy
  • Church of God Mission International

“I highly recommend Brett to any pastor who has a passion to produce fruit.”

Pastor Klayton Ko Senior Pastor, First Assembly of God, Red Hill, Hawaiʻi Six campuses across Oʻahu

The Problem

Why the same decision keeps coming back

This is the final book in the series. It is drafted and in editing, so chapter numbers may still move. The problems are settled.

The Elders Settled It In March And It Is On The Agenda Again.

A decision reopens when nobody agreed in advance what would count as a reason to close it.

Every Discussion Restarts From Nothing.

Without a stated order of reasons, each meeting relitigates what counts as evidence before it can discuss the actual question.

You Decide Alone And Carry It Alone.

Acts 15 is corporate for a reason, and using it does not mean handing the decision away.

You Made The Call And Cannot Tell Whether It Was Right.

Reviewing a decision without relitigating it is a separate skill, and most boards have only the second.

You Are About To Do Something Expensive To Reverse.

Building, hiring, splitting, planting. How much room to leave for being wrong is a question with a real answer.

Grounded in Acts 15 as a working model for how a group of leaders reaches a decision together.

What This Book Argues

  • How Scripture, the testimony of trusted people, and the evidence in front of you rank against each other : a stated hierarchy, so your disagreements are about the case instead of about what counts as a case.
  • Acts 15 read as a working model for corporate decision-making: what the council actually did, in what order, and why the sequence mattered as much as the conclusion.
  • How to test a decision against Scripture without reducing that test to proof-texting a conclusion you already reached.
  • Why leaving deliberate room for error is the wise position, and how much room a given decision warrants.
  • How a leadership team reaches a decision together without either deadlock or a single voice quietly carrying every vote.
  • What to do after the decision: how to tell whether it was right, and how to learn from it without relitigating it.
  • Which decisions a shepherd should refuse to make at all, and why declining is sometimes the decision.

Who This Is For

Elder Boards That Keep Revisiting The Same Question
Recurring decisions usually mean no one agreed what would settle it. This book is about fixing that upstream.
Pastors Who Decide Alone And Feel It
The Acts 15 model is corporate for a reason, and you still make the call.
Leaders Facing Something Genuinely Consequential
Building, hiring, splitting, planting. The chapters on margin for error are aimed at decisions that are expensive to reverse.
Anyone Who Has Watched A Good Church Make A Bad Call
Usually the process failed. The people were fine.

Not For: readers wanting a decision-making formula. The argument is that good decisions come from a stated order of reasons, which takes judgement to apply.

The Plan

Three steps, in this order

A decision reopens when nobody agreed in advance what would count as a reason to close it. Fix that once and most of the relitigating stops.

  1. Agree the order of reasons

    Scripture, then the testimony of trusted people, then the evidence in front of you. Settle the ranking before the contested question comes up.

  2. State what would close it

    Before you discuss, write down what would count as a reason to settle the matter. Without that, the most persistent voice wins by attrition.

  3. Decide Together, Then Review Without Reopening

    Acts 15 is the working model for a group of leaders reaching a decision. Reviewing a call and relitigating it are separate skills, and most boards only have the second.

The book works this through with the passages, the sequencing, and the question of how much room to leave for being wrong.

What pastors say about working with Brett

The Intensive marketing seminar opened our perspective to see marketing as ministry by showing us how to create a "funnel" system (Connect, convert, close) to move new visitors from the door to the core of the church. I highly recommend Brett to any pastor who has a passion to produce fruit. 5 STARS

— Pastor Klayton Ko, Senior Pastor, First Assembly of God, Red Hill, Hawaiʻi (six campuses across Oʻahu) clickmill.co

Absolutely amazing content and delivery. It Covered the basics of marketing and practical strategies to take my group to the next level. This course met a need I never knew I had.

— Pastor Frank, Connections Pastor clickmill.co

Clickmill has helped our church get more into the 21st century and to reach more people with the gospel. They are easy to work with and have been patient with us. Great company to partner with.

— Pastor Jonathan, First Baptist Church clickmill.co

Launch notice

Hear when this one lands.

Book Seven of The Shepherd’s Path, seven books on the practical work of leading a church. The list hears first, at launch pricing.

No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.

Before you start

Questions leaders ask first.

When Is This Published?

This is the earliest-stage book in the series. The teaching material exists and the structure is still being worked out, so it is the final volume and will be the last to arrive.

Join the list and you will hear when it moves.

Is This About Hearing From God, Or About Thinking Clearly?

Both, and the book holds them together. Scripture ranks first in the order of reasons; careful thinking is how you apply it to a situation Scripture does not address directly.

The series conviction throughout is that using your mind in ministry is an act of stewardship rather than a failure of faith.

Why Acts 15?

Because it is the clearest picture in Scripture of a group of leaders facing a genuinely contested question and reaching a decision together.

What the council did, and the order it did it in, turns out to be a workable model for a modern elder board.

Do I Need The Other Books First?

No. Every book in The Shepherd’s Path stands alone.

Cover of Resolving the Free Will Dilemma, Brett D. Henderson's book on predestination and free will

Free — the complete book

Get Book 1: Resolving the Free Will Dilemma free when you enter your name and email.

Volume One builds Frame-Indexed Classical Theism from its two axioms and applies it in full to Calvinism, Arminianism and Molinism. The standard objections are answered in the open.

No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.